Key Questions Answered
One way to represent the cost of exchanging value on a blockchain network is through asset tokenization, of which the assets can either be fungible or non-fungible. Fungible means they can be divided and exchanged for another. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs), on the other hand, cannot be divided and there are no existing duplicates. On a blockchain like Ethereum, two popular standards for creating NFTs exist, ERC-721 and ERC-1155.
What is the ERC-721 Standard?
Created by William Entriken, Dieter Shirley, Jacob Evans, and Natassia Sachs in 2018, the ERC-721 non-fungible token standard is written in Solidity language on the Ethereum blockchain and it allows developers to tokenize ownership of any arbitrary data. In particular, the standard aims to create interchangeable tokens. An example of an ERC 721 contract is from OpenZeppelin, which allows developers to track items in their game.
Essentially, each ERC 721 token is unique and represents a single asset. Moreover, it allows developers to build a whole new ecosystem of tokens on the Ethereum blockchain.
Characteristics of ERC-721 Tokens
The ERC-721 standard structurally resembles the ever-famous ERC-20 token architect. Although the smart contracts of both tokens have somewhat similar functions, some features of ERC-721 are different.
- Each ERC-721 token has a name field, which indicates the token name to external applications or contracts.
- It has a defined field of functions that defines the ownership of the underlying token and gives directions on how to transfer that ownership.
- It has a field called “tokenOfOwnerByIndex” that allows developers to track tokens through a unique ID.
What is The ERC-1155 Standard?
ERC-1155, an improved standard beyond ERC-721, is another token standard on the Ethereum blockchain that facilitates the creation of both kinds of tokens, fungible and non-fungible. The goal is to create a smart contract interface that can represent both types. Here is the ERC-1155 token code from OpenZipplin that helps track multiple items in a game.
The ERC-1155 standard, in particular, has the same functionality as an ERC-721 and ERC-20 token. However, it improves upon the functionality of both standards and is a more efficient standard overall. In terms of benefits, transactions using the ERC-1155 standard can be bundled together to help reduce the cost of trading tokens.
Benefits of ERC-1155 Tokens
- Effective Transfer: The ERC-1155 standard allows users to make massive transfers natively of the tokens within a smart contract. For example, in a smart contract with a series of fungible or non-fungible tokens, a developer can choose to transfer multiple tokens in the same operation. It not only reduces the transaction cost but also minimizes the impact on the network.
- Multiple Tokens in A Single Contract: Each ERC-1155 token describes the existence and operation of both the fungible and non-fungible token types. For example, while an ERC-1155 can create one or more NFTs, it can also describe fungible tokens – all within the same contract.
- Secure Transfer of Tokens: ERC-1155 token standard includes a function that checks whether a transaction is valid or not. If a transaction doesn’t go through, this function returns the token to the issuer. It helps when users accidentally make a mistake in the transcription or send out tokens to the wrong address. The code can automatically revert the transaction.
ERC-721 vs ERC-1155: The Difference
First, the ERC-721 standard produces NFTs solely and forces developers to create a smart contract for each new token. On the other hand, ERC-1155 allows developers to develop a single smart contract that can be used to mint either fungible tokens or NFTs. Since ERC-721 allows a single operation for each transaction, it is expensive and time-consuming. At the same time, it reduces the effectiveness of the blockchain network with redundant code. Whereas, ERC-1155 allows multiple operations in a single transaction. Therefore, the transactions are cheaper and more efficient. Plus, unlike ERC-721, which utilizes significant space, ERC-1155 uses less storage space on a blockchain network.
Which Is Better, ERC-721 or ERC-1155?
Both the token standards can mint NFTs. It leaves us with the question: which one should you prefer? It all depends upon your personal preference or the use case. While some art collectors only buy ERC-721 NFTs because they see this token type as the gold standard, other collectors do not have any specific preference. On the flip side, ERC-1155 is cheaper and efficient as it reduces the gas fees, making it an affordable and approachable way to mint an NFT.