logo
TradFi
Sign Up to 15,000 USDT in Rewards
Limited-time offer is waiting for you!

How to Read the Elder Force Index and When It Fails

Key Points

How to read the Elder Force Index: its formula, its zero line, the settings traders use, and how its dip signal did on 22 crypto perpetuals.

The Elder Force Index is Alexander Elder's indicator that multiplies each day's price change by its volume to show how hard buyers or sellers pushed. Above its zero line, buyers won the period you chose, and below it sellers did. The further the line runs from zero, the bigger the move or the heavier its volume.

Its textbook buy signal, a dip in the short-term line during an uptrend, trailed an ordinary day over five and ten days. On Phemex's daily bars for 22 crypto perpetuals from September 2024 to the mid-November close, 43.2% of 1,253 dips of the 2-day Force Index below zero in a rising 22-day average were followed by a higher close ten days later against 45.4% of all days.

Five days out, the dip did worst right after a coin had run up more than 10% in 20 days. By then, 40.6% of 680 such setups had closed higher, against 45.6% of all days. It edged past an ordinary day only at 20 days, and even then by less than the margin set before the test.

 

What Does the Force Index Do?

The Force Index tells you who controlled a stretch of trading and how hard they pushed. ChartSchool sums up Elder's idea this way. Every price move has a direction, an extent and a volume. The indicator folds them into one line that swings above and below zero.

Direction sets the sign. A close above the previous close gives a positive reading, and a close below it gives a negative one.

Extent and volume set the size, so a big move on heavy volume prints a tall reading while a small move on thin volume barely registers. In ChartSchool's words, "A big advance on heavy volume shows a strong commitment from buyers."

Traders put it to three uses. ChartSchool says it "can be used to reinforce the overall trend, identify playable corrections or foreshadow reversals with divergences." Buying a short dip inside an uptrend comes with the clearest rules of the three, so it's the one tested below.

Volume indicators differ in what they multiply volume by. The accumulation/distribution indicator weights each day's volume by where the close lands in the day's range, while the Force Index weights it by how far the close moved from the day before.

What Goes Into the Force Index Formula?

The formula needs two inputs a day, the close and the volume. It first appeared in Trading for a Living, Alexander Elder's 1993 book. ChartSchool's version comes down to three steps.

  1. Subtract the previous day's close from the day's close.

  2. Multiply the result by the day's volume to get the 1-day Force Index.

  3. Smooth the 1-day values with an exponential moving average, or EMA, an average that gives the newest days the most weight. A 13-day EMA of them is the 13-day Force Index.

On the 22 coins in the test, the raw 1-day line changed sign on about half of all days, which is why the smoothing matters. ChartSchool notes, "Elder recommends smoothing the indicator with a 13-period EMA to reduce the positive-negative crossovers."

Bitcoin's last setup in the test window shows the arithmetic at work. In early October, BTC slipped less than 1% in a day on about 80% more volume than the day before. That one day dragged the 2-day line below zero, because a 2-day EMA gives the newest day two-thirds of its weight.

One quirk trips people up. Each reading multiplies a price change by a volume, so its size depends on the coin's price and on the way a chart counts volume, in coins or in dollars. You can't compare a Bitcoin reading with one on a cheaper coin. Read the sign and the shape of the line, and leave the size alone.

Which Force Index Indicator Settings Do Traders Use?

Three lengths do most of the work, and each answers a different question.

  • The 2-day line is the fast one Elder pairs with a 22-day EMA to find pullbacks inside a trend, and it changed sign on more than a third of days on the 22 coins in the test.

  • The 13-day line is the default, smooth enough to show which side has controlled the last few weeks.

  • The 100-day line is the long-term read. "The bulls have the edge when the 100-day Force Index is positive," ChartSchool writes, and the bears have it when the line is negative.

ChartSchool also shows a 39-day version for medium-term swings and says "There is no right or wrong answer for these settings." A shorter length reacts faster and crosses zero more often. A longer one turns later but stays on one side of zero for longer.

ChartSchool treats the 100-day line as a filter for other signals. Its scan for pullbacks in an uptrend pairs a positive 100-day Force Index with an oversold reading on the CCI indicator. In a crypto test, though, the CCI's classic buy signal did no better than an ordinary day.

How Do You Use the Force Index Indicator on a Pullback?

The classic setup uses two lines, a 22-day EMA for the trend and a 2-day Force Index for the dip. In ChartSchool's words, "With the 22-day EMA rising, traders are looking for very short-term pullbacks when the 2-day Force Index turns negative."

The same logic runs in reverse in a downtrend. A falling 22-day EMA and a 2-day line turning positive mark a bounce to sell. ChartSchool calls the whole approach "an aggressive strategy best suited for active traders."

There are two ways to act on it. You can buy as soon as the 2-day line turns negative, or wait for it to climb back above zero as a sign the dip has ended. ChartSchool says the early entry may improve the reward-to-risk ratio, but warns that "the correction could extend a few more days."

On Bitcoin, the pieces looked like this to the mid-November close.

Signal
What it tells you
BTC on Phemex, to the mid-November close
1-day Force Index
Who won the day, and how hard
Below zero
13-day Force Index
Elder's default smoothing
Below zero
100-day Force Index
The long-term edge
Below zero
2-day dip in a rising 22-day EMA
A short pullback inside an uptrend
35 of 68 higher ten days on, vs 51.1% of all BTC days
A setup at the close
It needs a rising 22-day EMA
None, the 22-day EMA was falling
Last setup before the close
The most recent signal
Early October, then about 4.1% lower ten days on

That early-October setup came after BTC had run up about 13% in a few weeks, the kind of dip that fared worst over five days in the wider test. Five days on, BTC had closed about 3% lower, and 20 days on it was about 6.5% lower. Over the whole window, a Bitcoin setup was close to a coin flip, and about as good as any other day.

Where Did the Force Index Dip Signal Stop Working in Crypto?

The test marked every day the 2-day line crossed below zero while the 22-day EMA was rising, on 22 crypto perpetuals on Phemex, and took that day's close as the entry. It then checked the close five and ten days later, and again at 20 days, against every day on the same coins and against rising-EMA days with no setup.

The bar for an edge was fixed before any count. The setup had to beat those rising-EMA days by five points at ten days and show a higher median. It missed that bar at every holding period.

Days counted, September 2024 to mid-November
Higher close
Median change
Every day, 10 days on
45.4% of 17,380
-1.15%
Rising-EMA days without the setup, 10 days on
44.1% of 6,087
-1.43%
The dip setup, 10 days on
43.2% of 1,253
-2.18%
The dip setup, 5 days on (all days 45.6%)
42.6% of 1,253
-1.32%
The dip after a 10%+ run, 5 days on
40.6% of 680
-1.99%
The dip below the 200-day average, 10 days on
41.5% of 562
-2.57%
The dip setup, 20 days on (all days 43.2%)
44.8% of 1,251
-1.58%

Splitting the setups by what came before them showed where the signal broke. After a 20-day run of 10% or less, 45.0% of 573 dips had closed higher five days on, in line with an ordinary day. Most of the shortfall came from dips that followed a bigger run.

The setup beat its own market's rising-EMA days in only 8 of the 22 markets at ten days. Swapping the trend filter for a 13-day EMA barely moved the result, with 43.6% of its setups closing higher.

The sell version fared no better. A 2-day line turning positive while the 22-day EMA fell was followed by a lower close ten days later 53.4% of the time, against 54.5% of all days.

This is one window of history, with no fees, funding or stops. The 1,253 setups fell on 373 dates, so many of them were the same market move counted across coins.

The window also leaned down, with fewer than half of all ten-day stretches ending higher. The test bought the day the line turned negative. Waiting for the line to climb back above zero wasn't tested.

We'd read it this way. Over five and ten days, a quick dip right after a strong run was more often followed by further losses than a typical day was. Another momentum buy signal stumbled the same way. In a test on 17 crypto perpetuals, the TRIX indicator buy cross did worse than an ordinary day, and only its drop below zero held up.

Elder Force Index vs Elder Ray Index

Both come from Elder and both split the market into buyers and sellers, but they read different parts of the bar.

The Elder Ray Index measures how far each day's high and low reach from a 13-day EMA, which Incredible Charts' guide to it describes as "the market consensus of value." Bull Power is the high minus that EMA and Bear Power is the low minus it, with no volume in either one.

Its rules trade only in the direction of the EMA's slope. A long needs Bear Power below zero plus a bullish divergence, where price makes a lower low while the indicator makes a higher one.

The Force Index works from closes and volume, so it answers a different question. It tells you how much conviction backed the close, and Elder Ray tells you how far buyers or sellers could stretch price from its average during the day.

We'd use the Force Index when the doubt is about volume, and Elder Ray to see how far a trend has stretched.

How Can You Read the Force Index on Phemex Charts?

Phemex's futures chart lists the indicator as Elder's Force Index, with a length of 13 by default.

  1. Open the BTC/USDT futures chart and click D to switch to daily bars, the timeframe the test used.

  2. Click the Indicators icon above the chart, search "Force" and add Elder's Force Index. Its panel opens under the price chart, labelled EFI.

  3. Double-click the EFI label to open its settings. Keep 13 for the trend read, or set Length to 2 for the pullback setup and add Moving Average Exponential from the same list at a 22-day length.

  4. Read the line only after the daily bar closes, since the day's change and its volume keep moving until it closes.

Crypto trades around the clock, so a daily Force Index depends on where your chart ends each day. The VWAP indicator on a daily chart runs into the same issue.

On Phemex you can act on a long or a short read through BTC/USDT futures. Futures use leverage, and a leveraged position is closed automatically if losses push its margin below a set minimum.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Elder Force Index a leading or lagging indicator?

It lags by construction, because it's built from closes and volume that have already printed, then smoothed with an average. Its divergences from price are the closest it comes to leading, and ChartSchool says they can foreshadow reversals.

Why are Force Index values so large?

Each reading multiplies a price change by a volume, so the number mixes price units with coins or dollars. On Bitcoin it runs very large, and each coin prints on its own scale. Compare the sign and the shape over time, and leave the size alone.

What is the best time frame for the Elder Force Index strategy?

ChartSchool describes the pullback version with a 2-day Force Index and a 22-day EMA, which makes it a daily-bar trade. For medium-term traders it suggests trying a 10-day Force Index with a 100-day EMA. The crypto test covered the daily version only.

Bottom Line

The Force Index is at its best as a gauge of conviction, a way to see how much volume backs a move.

As a dip-buying trigger on crypto's daily bars, it called for buying where the odds in this test were among the weakest, right after a strong run paused for a day or two. We'd keep the 100-day line for direction and treat a fast dip after a big run as a warning sign.

 

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Cryptocurrency trading involves substantial risk. Always do your own research before making investment decisions.

Sign Up and Claim 15000 USDT
Disclaimer
This content provided on this page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, without representation or warranty of any kind. It should not be construed as financial, legal or other professional advice, nor is it intended to recommend the purchase of any specific product or service. You should seek your own advice from appropriate professional advisors. Products mentioned in this article may not be available in your region. Digital asset prices can be volatile. The value of your investment may go down or up and you may not get back the amount invested. For further information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure